For a better experience, click the Compatibility Mode icon above to turn off Compatibility Mode, which is only for viewing older websites.

Appellate Litigation Clinic Wins Case in US Court of Appeals

May 4, 2011

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has reinstated a lawsuit against a recycling company in Elkhart, Ind., marking a victory for citizens represented by students from the Appellate Litigation Clinic of the Earle Mack School of Law at Drexel University.

In a 50-page decision handed down on May 3, the court ruled that citizens may sue VIM Recycling Inc. for polluting air and water in their community, even though the state has also taken the company to court.

Kelly Payne, a 3L, had gone to Chicago to appear before the judges in January, arguing that the citizens’ complaint raised separate issues from a suit filed by the state of Indiana.  Specifically, Payne noted that the citizens’ suit addressed types of solid waste that were not covered by state regulations. She also argued that the lower court’s dismissal of the private suit contradicted the intent of congress in passing the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act to allow citizens to pursue legal claims on their own.  

Michael Sanford, also a 3L, had worked with Payne on writing briefs for the case as a part of the law school’s Appellate Litigation Clinic, which is led by Professor Richard Frankel.

“They both mastered very complex legal doctrines and were able to demonstrate the hardship that would befall real people,” Frankel said.  “They explained very clearly how the district court got it wrong when it dismissed the citizens’ suit.”

Sanford called his work “an incredible experience.”

Payne said it was gratifying to collaborate with Sanford and Frankel on the brief and the oral arguments.  

“I’m very grateful to Drexel for giving me and the other students in the clinic the opportunity to work on a case like this,” she said.

It’s remarkable for students to have arguments cited in a published appellate decision that makes law, Frankel said.

Even more importantly, Frankel said, the decision by the Seventh Circuit benefits citizens in every community.

“The decision upholds the rights of plaintiffs to enforce environmental laws and to keep companies accountable for their impact on the environment in the communities in which they operate,” Frankel added.

The Appellate Litigation Clinic allows students to provide legal services to individuals and organizations that would otherwise not be able to obtain representation.  The clinic handles a wide range of cases that involve constitutional, criminal, and immigration law, as well as the rights of the indigent and the incarcerated.  Students working under Frankel’s close supervision gain extensive hands-on experience in appellate advocacy, practice, and strategy.


News Media Contacts:
Alex McKechnie, News Officer, University Communications, 215-895-2705 or
Sarah Greenblatt, Communications Manager, Earle Mack School of Law, 215-571-4804 or

Topical Tags:

news release